 |
|
The Words and Music of Frank Zappa
Lowe, Kelly Fisher |
| |
Praeger Publishers
2006
ISBN: 0-275-98779-5
260 pp, hardcover, 24 x 16 cm
English |
Charles Ulrich @
alt.fan.frank-zappa:
I'm afraid the title is a misnomer. The book is primarily about
FZ's lyrics, with little about his music. Lowe admits on page xvii
that "I am much more at home working with lyrics than I am working
with music".
(...)
As for his discussion of FZ's lyrics, I'd say it tells you more
about Kelly Fisher Lowe than it does about Frank Zappa. In that
respect, it was reminiscent of Ben Watson's Negative Dialectics Of
Poodle Play (not that Watson's book tells us much about Lowe). But I
think Watson would acknowledge that his interpretations of FZ's
lyrics don't necessarily reflect FZ's own intentions--and argue that
there's no reason they should. On the other hand, I get the feeling
that Lowe believes he really is describing FZ's feelings. And he
hasn't persuaded me that he's right.
(...)
I'm not sorry I read it, but it wouldn't be the first book that I'd
recommend to someone looking for a book on FZ.
Kelly Fisher Lowe @
alt.fan.frank-zappa:
It was not, and was never, intended to be an academic book. In
fact, upon delivery of the original manuscript, I was asked to
revise it for a more general audience. My only "scholarly" hope was
to collect some of the loose bibliographic information in one place
so someone working on Zappa in the future would have an easier time
of it.
(...)
it's not a fan's book – by that I mean that Zappa's fans have a
unique relationship to him and I had no illusions that I would be
shedding any new light on Zappa's music (which was never the purpose
of the book). It was, and is, my only hope that someone would
stumble across the book in a library, get interested in Zappa, and
check him and his music out. Period.
Zappa Wiki Jawaka
The Idiot
|